The Invisible Weather Around Galaxies: A Story Told Through Mg II

What is this paper about?

The paper investigates how Mg II absorption systems—identified in the spectra of distant quasars—have evolved over the past 13 billion years, from the earliest epochs of galaxy formation (z ≈ 7) to the present Universe (z ≈ 0). Magnesium II (Mg II) absorption lines are highly reliable indicators of cool, metal-enriched gas in the circumgalactic medium (CGM) and intergalactic medium (IGM). When gas lies along the line of sight to a quasar, it leaves identifiable absorption signatures, allowing astronomers to measure metal content, gas flows, and chemical evolution indirectly across cosmic time.

The significance of this paper lies in constructing a single, unified, statistical model of how Mg II absorber populations evolve—rather than examining narrow redshift ranges or only strong systems, as many earlier studies did. By examining the full range of absorber strengths, the authors reconstruct a continuous timeline of metal-bearing gas around galaxies.

This timeline informs key questions in galaxy evolution:

• When did galaxies enrich their halos with metals?
• When was gas most turbulent and energetic?
• When did halos stabilize into the structures we observe today?

Ultimately, the paper uses Mg II absorbers as a cosmic fossil record to map the rise, peak, and settling of star-forming galaxies across the age of the Universe.

What the authors did

The authors set out to construct the most complete and self-consistent picture to date of how Mg II absorbers evolve across cosmic time, which required tackling multiple challenges simultaneously: a fragmented observational landscape, uneven redshift coverage, and the fact that different surveys use different equivalent-width thresholds and selection functions. Instead of treating Mg II absorber statistics in isolated redshift slices, the authors unified all available measurements into a single statistical framework capable of evolving smoothly from z ≈ 7 to z ≈ 0.

Their first step was to assemble a dataset covering the number of Mg II absorbers per unit absorption path length (dN/dX) across a wide range of redshifts. Each measurement corresponds to the number of absorption systems detected along many quasar sightlines, corrected for survey completeness. Crucially, the authors did not merely count “strong absorbers” (W > 1 Å) as most historical studies do; instead, they worked with the full distribution of absorber strengths, measured by rest-frame equivalent width (W). Equivalent width captures the total absorption strength, integrating both column density and velocity spread, making it a robust proxy for gas richness and dynamical state.

Because the population of absorbers spans many orders of magnitude in strength, the authors modeled the equivalent-width distribution using a Schechter-type function, widely used in astrophysics to characterize populations that have a power-law behavior at small values and an exponential decline at high values. For each redshift ( z ), they assumed the differential number of absorbers with equivalent width ( W ) is given by:

Here:

• ( \Phi_*(z) ) sets the overall abundance of absorbers,
• ( W_*(z) ) determines the transition point between the power-law and exponential regimes,
• ( \alpha(z) ) describes the slope of the power-law tail, and thus the relative abundance of weak absorbers.

A major innovation of the paper is that all three parameters are treated as functions of redshift, rather than fixed quantities. This means the authors are effectively asking:

• How does the population normalization evolve?
• How does the characteristic width shift?
• How does the faint-end slope develop as galaxies mature?

By allowing the parameters to evolve continuously, they produce a nonparametric evolutionary reconstruction, ensuring that the full equivalent-width distribution can be inferred at any redshift, even if individual surveys lack data at that epoch.

However, the available observations—especially at high redshift (z > 4)—are biased toward strong absorbers, since weak systems are harder to detect and thus underrepresented in catalogues. To handle this incompleteness transparently rather than forcing a single interpretation, the authors developed two bounding scenarios:

• Scenario A: The weak-absorber incidence does not decline at high redshift (i.e., ( \alpha(z) ) remains relatively stable), implying enrichment processes began early.
• Scenario B: Weak absorbers are less common at early times (i.e., ( \alpha(z) ) steepens with redshift), implying slower enrichment and more compact early halos.

The authors fitted the model under both scenarios across the entire redshift range using likelihood maximization techniques and uncertainty propagation to recover the best-fitting evolutionary trajectories of ( \Phi_(z) ), ( W_(z) ), and ( \alpha(z) ). These fits were then validated against all available dN/dX measurements, so that the inferred equivalent-width distributions could be converted into absorber incidence curves and compared directly with observations.

Through this approach, the paper does not reinterpret past observational results—it interpolates and unifies them, producing a continuous history of Mg II absorber evolution that bridges gaps in the data while remaining anchored to empirical measurements.

Key findings

The analysis conducted in this paper yields a remarkably structured — and previously unseen — evolutionary history of Mg II absorbers across 13 billion years of cosmic time. Rather than showing a monotonic rise or decline, Mg II absorption evolves in three distinct phases, reflecting the changing physical state of gaseous halos surrounding galaxies (the CGM) and their connection to star-formation activity.

The first finding is that in the early Universe (z > 5), Mg II absorbers — especially weak absorbers — appear to be relatively rare. This result holds under the authors’ preferred high-redshift scenario where the slope ( \alpha(z) ) becomes more negative at early times, suppressing the low-equivalent-width end of the distribution. Physically, this suggests that the CGM had not yet been significantly metal-enriched, and that large-scale galactic inflows and feedback-driven outflows had not fully propagated metals into halos. The Universe was in a stage where galaxies were forming stars rapidly but had not yet filled their surroundings with heavy elements. Mg II here acts as a tracer of that delay.

The most striking result is the behavior of Mg II systems around Cosmic Noon (z ≈ 1–3) — the epoch corresponding to the peak of star formation and stellar feedback in the Universe. In this period, both the normalization ( \Phi_(z) ) and the characteristic equivalent width ( W_(z) ) reach their maximum values, indicating that strong Mg II absorbers become dramatically more common. Observationally, that translates to a rapid rise in the number of systems with ( W \gtrsim 1\,\text{Å} ). The exponential portion of the Schechter distribution becomes dominant, meaning that the strongest, most metal-rich, kinematically complex gas systems are preferentially produced. This is consistent with physical models in which galaxies at Cosmic Noon generate intense feedback — from supernovae, stellar winds, and AGN — injecting metals, turbulence, and bulk velocity flows into the CGM.

After Cosmic Noon, the absorber population transitions again. In the last eight billion years (z < 1), the number of strong absorbers declines, indicated by a drop in ( W_*(z) ) and a reduction in the exponential component of the distribution. However, weak absorbers continue to rise in abundance, driven by a flattening of the faint-end slope ( \alpha(z) ). In other words, the Mg II population becomes dominated by numerous weak systems rather than fewer strong ones. This shift signals the onset of CGM stabilization: metals become more uniformly dispersed, the gas becomes dynamically cooler, and turbulence decreases as the cosmic star-formation rate declines. The CGM still contains metals — perhaps even more than during Cosmic Noon — but they are distributed in less extreme dynamical environments.

The cumulative finding is that Mg II absorbers do not merely increase or decrease across time — they change character. The early Universe lacked widespread metal-bearing halos; Cosmic Noon produced violent, metal-rich gas capable of generating strong absorption; and the late Universe fostered stable, extended, lower-energy halos rich in weak absorbing systems.

By tracking the separate evolution of ( \Phi_(z) ), ( W_(z) ), and ( \alpha(z) ), the authors demonstrate that each phase of cosmic history leaves a measurable imprint on the equivalent-width distribution. The rise and fall of strong systems, alongside the late-time proliferation of weak systems, paints a compelling story: the CGM evolves from primitive → turbulent → structured, mirroring — almost perfectly — the lifecycle of galaxies themselves.

Why this matters — astrophysical relevance

The importance of this paper extends far beyond cataloging Mg II absorbers; it directly informs how we understand the formation, evolution, and eventual decline of galaxies across cosmic time. Mg II absorption traces cool, metal-enriched gas, which is the material galaxies rely on to form stars. Unlike stars or dark matter, gas is dynamic — it flows inward, fuels star formation, gets expelled by feedback, cools, returns, and cycles again. This cyclical movement, known as the baryon cycle, determines whether a galaxy grows efficiently, stagnates, or collapses into quiescence. Mg II absorption provides a quantitative tracer of that cycle.

The strong rise of Mg II absorbers during Cosmic Noon reveals that this epoch was not simply a time of high star formation; it was a time when metals were being pushed into the CGM in enormous quantities by powerful winds and outflows. This supports a physical picture in which star formation does not occur in isolation — galaxies pollute and reshape their surroundings as they form stars. When the paper shows that Mg II absorbers peak at Cosmic Noon and decline afterward, it provides empirical evidence that feedback-driven turbulence in the CGM slows down as star-formation activity falls.

The late-time increase in weak Mg II absorbers matters just as much. These systems imply that although star formation has slowed, metals remain present and widespread, but the surrounding gas has cooled and stabilized. Instead of violent winds and dense clumps, the modern CGM contains quiescent, diffuse, but enriched gas reservoirs. This tells us that galaxies in the present Universe live in a more controlled, stable fueling environment compared to their ancestors.

This evolutionary sequence helps answer several long-standing questions:

• Why did star formation peak early and decline later?
  Because the CGM transitioned from a high-energy feedback-dominated phase to a lower-energy, cooling-driven phase.

• How early did galaxies enrich their halos?
  The scarcity of weak absorbers at high redshift suggests that enrichment lagged behind star formation in the Universe’s first billion years.

• Is the CGM a regulator of galaxy growth?
  The match between Mg II evolution and the star-formation history of the Universe strongly supports this idea.

Ultimately, the astrophysical relevance of the paper lies in demonstrating that galaxy evolution cannot be understood without understanding the gaseous ecosystems around them. Stars form inside galaxies, but the conditions that allow or prevent star formation are written into the metal absorption signatures of the CGM. This work shows that Mg II is more than a spectral feature — it is a chronicle of galaxy growth encoded in light.

Limitations

The authors highlight several limitations that shape the certainty of their conclusions. The most prominent challenge is the lack of high-redshift observations for weak Mg II absorbers. Surveys at z > 5 are still sparse and typically biased toward detecting only strong systems. This means that the behavior of ( \alpha(z) ), which encodes the slope of the weak-absorber population, is not empirically well constrained in the earliest epochs. To account for this, the authors model two scenarios, but fully resolving this ambiguity requires future spectroscopic campaigns.

A second limitation is the degeneracy of equivalent width. Although W scales with column density and metal content, it is also influenced by velocity dispersion, ionization fraction, and geometric covering factor. Disentangling these physical components requires complementary diagnostics, not only Mg II.

Another limitation arises from the line-of-sight nature of quasar spectroscopy. Each quasar provides only one narrow probe through the CGM, requiring population-level inference. This approach is statistically powerful but loses information about spatial variations within individual halos or differences between galaxy types.

Finally, the assumption of a smooth functional evolution in ( \Phi_(z) ), ( W_(z) ), and ( \alpha(z) ) may smooth out sharp physical transitions, such as those triggered by reionization or AGN-driven feedback. This does not invalidate the model but sets boundaries on its interpretive resolution.

Relation to other work and future directions

This work sits within the broader effort to understand the multi-phase CGM using quasar absorption systems. Earlier studies have mapped other ions:

• O I, C II for neutral cold gas,
• C IV, Si IV for warm ionized gas,
• O VI for hot, collisionally ionized gas.

Together, these tracers build a layered view of halos. Mg II complements them by accessing dense, cool, metal-bearing gas, which plays a decisive role in fueling star formation. By spanning 13 billion years, this paper builds a framework that other CGM studies can anchor onto.

The most immediate future directions emerge from the paper’s high-redshift predictions:

• If galaxies enriched their halos rapidly, the earliest quasar sightlines should reveal a dense “Mg II forest.”
• If enrichment was delayed, high-z spectra should show large metal-free gaps.

Both possibilities are testable.

Several upcoming observational tools will directly evaluate these predictions:

• JWST NIRSpec high-redshift quasar programs
• Gravitationally lensed quasar spectroscopy (for higher signal-to-noise)
• 30-meter class telescopes enabling deep surveys beyond z > 6

On the theoretical side, cosmological simulations can use this model as an empirical benchmark, tuning feedback and metal transport models to reproduce the evolution of ( \Phi_(z) ), ( W_(z) ), and ( \alpha(z) ). If matched successfully, Mg II could become a standard calibration probe for galaxy evolution physics across cosmic time.

Source: Download Paper (PDF)